Three Easy Steps to Block Sites in Turkey

Submitted by Jillian C. York on 25 September, 2008 - 16:12.

Posted in Arrests and legal action, Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS), Defamation, Legislation, Social filtering, Take-down, Turkey

In a clear instance of vexatious litigation, a Turkish court has blocked the Web site of prominent evolutionist Richard Dawkins following complaints from Islamic creationist and author Adnan Oktar. Oktar, who writes under the nom de plume Harun Yahya, filed the complaint last week; when Turkish Internet users now attempt to access Dawkins' site, they are presented with a message that reads: 'access to this site has been suspended in accordance with a court decision'.

This is not the first time Oktar has been involved in such litigation. In April 2007, Oktar successfully filed a defamation complaint against Turkish online news site Eksi sozluk. Oktar filed the complaint because of comments that users of Eksi sozluk had posted about him; a similar site, Superpoligon, was also blocked. Access to Eksi sozluk was restored shortly after the complaints were filed, and the offending remarks removed by the site's administrator.

Less than four months later, Oktar appealed to Wordpress.com to remove a number of blogs which he deemed slanderous. Following an unfavorable reaction from Wordpress, Oktar again filed a complaint with the Turkish judicial system, which in turn blocked Wordpress within Turkey. Oktar's complaint was based on a number of blogs created by rival Edip Yuksel, a prominent dissident. To date, Wordpress remains blocked, despite numerous campaigns to unblock the site. Turkish bloggers now use Wordprexy, a mirror site set up by activist group Great Firewall of Turkey, to read and post to Wordpress blogs. Less than six months later, Oktar filed a complaint against Google Groups, which led to that site being blocked within Turkey as well (Google.com remained accessible; only the subdomain groups.google.com was filtered). It is once again available.

Oktar's latest rancor is directed at Richard Dawkins, a British ethologist and evolutionary biologist. Following the release of Oktar's creationist book, Atlas of Creation, Dawkins wrote on his Web site:

"I am at a loss to reconcile the expensive and glossy production values of this book with the breathtaking inanity of the content."

Oktar, who was involved in the attempt to ban Dawkins' book The God Delusion in Turkey, retaliated by filing a complaint in regards to Dawkins' Web site. A Turkish judicial court sided with Oktar, and ordered Turk Telecom to ban the site.

In each instance, the foreign press was quick to assume that the blockings were related to Turkey's rising Islamist party, the AKP. It is perhaps more alarming that politics had little to do with it. It is surprising that Oktar, considered a charlatan by the Turkish public, and having so recently run afoul of the law, carries so much weight in the Turkish judicial system.

In fact, Oktar carries neither more nor less weight than anyone else. According to a recent Reuters article, a law passed in May now allows the Telecommunications Directorate to close down websites based on complaints by individual users, thus enabling anyone with a complaint to get a site blocked. The problem therefore lies in the ease with which anyone can file such a complaint.

On Oktar's Web site, HarunYahya.com, there is a quote from the Qur'an: "Truth has come and falsehood has vanished. Falsehood is always bound to vanish." If Dawkins' work is the falsehood Oktar is referencing, then indeed he has succeeded in making it "vanish"...if only from the Turkish Internet.

thanks a lot for solving and

Submitted by b&b barcelona (not verified) on 4 February, 2010 - 07:17.

thanks a lot for solving and explaining this issue.

thanks

Submitted by MMA Pound For Pound (not verified) on 1 February, 2010 - 16:58.

Astaga.com Lifestyle on The Net | Festival Museum Nusantara | Indonesia Java International Destination

Increase Your Traffic With Klikrar | nowGoogle.com Adalah Multiple Search Engine Popular | MMA Pound For Pound | Festival Museum Nusantara | Beritajitu.com - Berita Jitu gak jitu gak malu
i will be back later thanks you

Agreed

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on 31 January, 2010 - 22:55.

Government should be the final authority to block or unblock web site. Essay Editing

Turkey Censorship

Submitted by Turkey (not verified) on 31 January, 2010 - 09:46.

His type of censorship should not be allowed in Turkey or anywhere else.

Blumen verschicken

Submitted by Blumen verschicken (not verified) on 30 January, 2010 - 10:33.

I have webspace in Turkey and i am not really pleased lately. Their justice system is kinda crazy. Thanks for the article.

Regards

Turkey

Submitted by Blumen verschicken (not verified) on 30 January, 2010 - 10:32.

I have webspace in Turkey and i am not really pleased lately. Their justice system is kinda crazy. Thanks for the article.

Regards

confuse

Submitted by 4multimaster (not verified) on 29 January, 2010 - 04:43.

I am quite confuse with the article .

rockwell sonicrafter
rockwell sonicrafter

Turkey Censorship

Submitted by Turkey (not verified) on 31 January, 2010 - 09:50.

You should not be confused, it is a clear case of censorship.

confuse

Submitted by 4multimaster (not verified) on 29 January, 2010 - 04:42.

I am quite confuse with the article .

rockwell sonicrafter
rockwell sonicrafter
rockwell sonic crafter
fein multimaster top

sfafI really like your topic .. Topics I've shared your facebook

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on 3 February, 2010 - 12:03.

I really like your topic .. Topics I've shared your facebook .. Thank you very much again .. In addition, I gave my site a few below, if you like it, you'll be glad to sites in and make comments

borsa forum canl? borsa
chat chat
müzik indir dizi izle
müjde ar film izle
kemal sunal film izle lig tv izle

lig tv canl?
justin tv izle Canl? maç izle
lpg
teleflex lpg Arama Motoru
Hitkazan askerlik
?afak hesaplama program?
Edu-Egitim Online Ders
çizgi film izle
kayu izle ürün tan?t?m scripti
web tasar?m
onlinesitem Video izle
msn sözleri
güzel sözler oyun indir
havuz dizi izle
polis videolar? polis video
3g video

Thanks admin ..
George

easy as one, two, three

Submitted by custom essay (not verified) on 29 January, 2010 - 04:15.

woah great tips here...thanks very much! My boyfriend is currently in Turkey and was asking me about this voila I can now teach him now I can even write my essay about it...:)

naperville dentist aurora

Submitted by make money online (not verified) on 28 January, 2010 - 13:09.

naperville dentist
aurora dentist
online pharmacy
chicago movers
make money online
internet tips
tips
work from home
video tips
Shopping Tips
Car Tips
Computer Tips
Travel Tips
Finance Tips

That's not good. Everybody

Submitted by Ryan Walters (not verified) on 28 January, 2010 - 01:46.

That's not good. Everybody does have the freedom to look on those websites. Government should not ban those sites.

Ryan Walters
Research paper help

thanks

Submitted by sdf (not verified) on 3 February, 2010 - 12:05.

thanks

Thanks brother was very nice

Submitted by oyun (not verified) on 27 January, 2010 - 10:42.

Thanks brother was very nice of page
siki?
oyun
film izle
dizi izle
oyunlar

swff

Submitted by fwe (not verified) on 3 February, 2010 - 12:04.

I really like your topic .. Topics I've shared your facebook .. Thank you very much again .. In addition, I gave my site a few below, if you like it, you'll be glad to sites in and make comments

borsa forum canl? borsa
chat chat
müzik indir dizi izle
müjde ar film izle
kemal sunal film izle lig tv izle

Thanks admin ..
George

replica jewelry

Submitted by replica jewelry (not verified) on 26 January, 2010 - 22:16.

Wholesale Jewelry Shop

The Fashion Replica Bags
China market Versace Bags Replica
Replica Louis Vuitton Bags
is growing Rolex Replica Watches
fast. Watches Replica
Beside Laser Pendant Wholesale Jewelry
the tiffany rings
Wholesale Jewelry Shop
global Fashion Pendant
downturn, which affects Gucci Leather Handbags Replica
Stainless Steel Necklace Fashion
every Aigner Watch Replica
country, China is Luxury Handbags
quite stable, Michele Norsa, chief Chanel Watches Replica
Chanel Replica Bags
executive of Wholesale Jewelry Tools
Salvatore Ferragamo Small Necklace jewelry Wholesale
Fake Corum
SpA, Tiffany Jewelry Rings
said in an e-mail Fake Audemars Piguet
response to Tiffany sale
questions. Stone Rings Fashion
Wholesale Titanium Bracelet
""Definitively, we Wholesale Stainless Steel Earring
Chanel Wallet Fake
are yiwu jewelry Magnet Necklace factory
optimistic.Ferragamo plans Cutting Rings Tungsten Jewelry
to Jaeger Lecoultre Replica Watches
Fake Raymond Weil
add Wholesale Jewelry Video
seven Wholesale Titanium Jewelry jewelry
to eight China Replica Louis Vuitton 2007
stores Piaget Watch Replica
this year, Franck Muller Watch
with Replica Omega
Giverchy Replica Handbags
further Bell & Ross Replica Watches
expansion Replica Miu Miu
in Replica Concord Watch
2010, according to Replica Clothing and Shoes
Norsa.

replica watches

Submitted by replica watches (not verified) on 26 January, 2010 - 22:14.

China LED Ribbon Light|High Power LED Bulbs|
Replica Watches,Fake Watches,Replica Watch,Fake Watch,Wholesale Watches,Wholesale Replica Watches,Jewelry Watches,Replica Jewelry Watches.

Thank

Submitted by ilan bir (not verified) on 26 January, 2010 - 16:19.

brahm samaj have a mission to unite all Brahmin community to work for Brahminism

ilan Ver
Araba ilanlar?

My position

Submitted by 4multimaster (not verified) on 26 January, 2010 - 11:52.

This clearly is a instance of vexatious litigation, that has been taken by the court.

sectional sofas
rockwell sonicrafter

Hey thats very cool article.

Submitted by evden eve nakliye (not verified) on 25 January, 2010 - 19:23.

Hey thats very cool article. antalya haber
Can I post it to my blog evden eve nakliye
antalya ve ilçeleri aras1nda nakliyat yap1l1r. evden eve nakliye de bir numara site.Bu site evden eve nakliyat
kullanmaktad1r. Seo uzmanlar1 arama motorlar1 optimizasyonu yapar. Mesela Samanyolu dizisi özcan deniz'in dizisidir. 2010 ygs sorular1
de seo uzman1 kullan1r. Öss s1nav1 yakla_1yor. Öss bu sene isim dei_tirdi ve ad1 2010 YGS LYS oldu. 2010 Ygs sorular1

Blocked Websites in Turkey

Submitted by Saibot (not verified) on 24 January, 2010 - 23:38.

Its saddens me to hear the Turkish Goverments decision.

apple macbook laptop aquos

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on 24 January, 2010 - 11:58.

apple macbook laptop
aquos lcd hdtv
best cordless phones
best cordless phones
best cordless phones
ConsumerReviewsTv
blu ray dvd player
buy cheap dvd movies online
buy cheap games online
buy led hdtv
cheap garmin nuvi garmin gps navigator
bestbuy-electronics
cheap textbooks online
coolpix-s230-630-220.p90.l100
electric-cookware
film-cameras-shop
fuji-digital-cameras
customerproductreviews
ipod-mp3-player
juicers-breville-juicer
kindle-2.battery.accessories
logitech.drivers.harmony
lucien.piccard.watches
HomeElectronicsReviews
new-ipod-best-buy
nintendo.wii.games.store
norcent.store
nuvi-885t-855.zumo-660
oppo.digital.dvd
DigitalCameraConsumerReview
panasonic-dmp-bd55k-35-20
panasonic.viera.g10-x1-s1
plasma-tv-deals
printers-shop
pure.camcorder.store
productreviewsoftware
samsung-led-8000
samsung-led-8500
samsung-series-9-8-7-5-4
samsung.lcd.tv.hdtv.store
samsungln46b750-650
NetbooksReviews
samsungln52b750-650-550
taylormade.golf
timothys.world.coffee.store
vintage.cartier.watch
vizio.led.tv
western.digital.store
Thailand on tours
new cellphones reviews

My position

Submitted by Rockwell Sonicrafter (not verified) on 24 January, 2010 - 11:29.

My position is that the documentation of this matter is abundant and conclusive. People who block relevant generic pharmacy sites, in contrast, argue that they can convince criminals to fill out an application form before committing a crime. This disagreement merely scratches the surface of the ideological chasm festering between me and those who choose block relevant sites.

ilahiler

Submitted by ilahiler (not verified) on 24 January, 2010 - 08:44.

Submitted by ilahi dinle (not verified)thank you very much

This disagreement merely

Submitted by siomy (not verified) on 22 January, 2010 - 07:09.

This disagreement merely scratches the surface of the ideological chasm festering between me and those who choose block relevant sites.Online university | online post graduate certificate bussiness | online post graduate certificate

worpress gaming blog

Submitted by pc games 2010 - video games (not verified) on 22 January, 2010 - 02:47.

PES 2010 PC Game

"PES is renewed completely,"

Pro Evolution Soccer 2010 is the latest chapter of a prestigious lineage, the football made in Konami. The eternal rival FIFA has done his homework: he is now more realistic and detailed than before. And it shows.

Pro Evolution Soccer 2010 steps on the accelerator of the simulation. While the 2009 version had a decidedly arcade flavor, the most notable improvement of PES 2010 is the highest likelihood in the management of players and ball. The ball obeys the laws of physics better, and weather effects are left with greater insistence notice.

The players of Pro Evolution Soccer 2010 appear more solid, thanks in part to the new collision detection. They are also more similar to the originals, not only by the fidelity with which the faces have been reproduced, but also by the detail with which Konami has compiled statistics and special abilities of each.

The menus have been completely transformed. Browse through the options of Pro Evolution Soccer 2010 is a completely different experience. They have more volume and better organized. Appear, moreover, the sliders, a revolution for players who like to maximize their equipment.

Pro Evolution Soccer 2010 has all the requirements to breathe new life into one of the most successful football simulation ever. Will they?
Note on Pro Evolution Soccer 2010:

It is possible that the download link is saturated at the moment
Limitations of the trial:

You can play a friendly with F.C. Barcelona, Liverpool and selections from Spain, Germany, Italy and France
For Pro Evolution Soccer 2010 we will need:

* Operating System: WinXP/Vista/7

Video Games 2009

very interesting article,

Submitted by William Hill (not verified) on 21 January, 2010 - 16:01.

very interesting article, thanks man !

Yeast Infection Pictures

Submitted by MichelleLim (not verified) on 21 January, 2010 - 14:59.

Yeast Infection Pictures

KeyifLi SiteLer <<<<

Submitted by Uzman (not verified) on 21 January, 2010 - 09:21.

muhabbet
urfa
?anl?urfa
?anl? urfa haber
?anl? urfa
Chat
bitanem
muhabbet

very helpful

Submitted by sexytats (not verified) on 20 January, 2010 - 21:16.

Good Article! I like this post. thank for your sharing ... very helpful for me :)

Re

Submitted by yBGEENA (not verified) on 20 January, 2010 - 17:16.

All the time, scholars would like to cognise the mastery of productive persuasive essay accomplishing. Your superior theme close to this topic would become a correct ground for that people. I get know that even buy essay service takes some articles as a ground for the online term papers. Hence, your writing skillfulness is quite useful for people.

Re

Submitted by EllieXU (not verified) on 20 January, 2010 - 13:35.

Essays online service should follow your excellent outcome just about this post in argument essay accomplishing. Moreover, you have to be a great tutor in that business.

nice post

Submitted by sexytats (not verified) on 20 January, 2010 - 07:37.

My questions 've been answered by your wonderful write. Very well said info and tips. Thank you so much for this sharing.Sexy Tattoo Girls|Free Nod32 ID Pass

Achy Obejas

Submitted by Achy Obejas (not verified) on 20 January, 2010 - 06:31.

I completely agree with you! In search for marriage? You had many terrible time with women from your city, and looking for another choices. Can't find anywhere? And you may not get one without our help. Why? That's because you are searching in wrong places. We present you information to thousand data of girls your age, from thousand cities. All you need is pay for membership. We present you all year, it's trouble-free for you. Get your true love with finest dating site ever. Best wishes from russian dating service, dating a russian girl, russian school girls, russian girls in brooklyn, marriage russian

Achy Obejas

Submitted by Achy Obejas (not verified) on 20 January, 2010 - 06:30.

Great post, and I agree with you! What everybody are looking: good buiseness? Capital? Or just unbelievable connection? The responce will be obviously LOVE, dating russian woman. How affluent you would not be you possess, it's not that important if your heart it's pour - russian single dating. I think you have noticed this, and what is the problem: bride dating russian? Leave all your work for a second and take your time and think about that for a moment. You need living like this, russian dating and marriage? Then if you don't, then this blog is the thing only for you. Make yourself a user, and place your flag at Everest of russian dating chat.

Generic Viagra | Cheap

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on 18 January, 2010 - 08:09.

Generic Viagra | Cheap Generic Viagra | Generic Viagra | Medicines Drop Shipping

Sí tan fresco, señor gran

Submitted by dayak (not verified) on 17 January, 2010 - 10:59.

Reoccuring YEast infection

Submitted by Michelle Lim (not verified) on 17 January, 2010 - 00:09.

Reoccuring Yeast Infection

Nice Post ! !

Submitted by Mr.Doors (not verified) on 16 January, 2010 - 23:48.

Thank for sharing ^ ^

Closet Doors

Thanks

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on 16 January, 2010 - 18:42.

Thanks for sharing
Scooter |
Destockage |
Nettoyage

interesting

Submitted by betclic (not verified) on 16 January, 2010 - 15:54.

Thanks.

no

Submitted by comparateur de cotes (not verified) on 16 January, 2010 - 15:51.

Very interesting article, thank you.
check out : http://www.comparateur-de-cotes.fr

timberland roll top boots

Submitted by timberland roll top boots (not verified) on 15 January, 2010 - 03:16.

cheap timberland boots sale on timberland store,timberland pro work boots,timberland roll top sale ,work boots ,timberland 6 inch boots,free shipping!

great article

Submitted by Essay Writers (not verified) on 14 January, 2010 - 21:18.

your article is great, I have learned a lot from reading it. I just wanted to thank you because you're giving me an idea on what topic I'm going to do with my essay. Your post really helps!

love it

Submitted by video izle (not verified) on 14 January, 2010 - 09:20.

love it

can i post this article on

Submitted by SEO Dubai (not verified) on 13 January, 2010 - 07:33.

can i post this article on my blog ???

nikky
Dubai Hotels , Rent a car in Dubai , Dubai 5 Star Hotels , Dubai Hotel Apartments

I think it will be better to

Submitted by Luxurious Bali Villas and Accommodations (not verified) on 13 January, 2010 - 02:11.

I think it will be better to educate people about the websites rather than blocking them.

Agree :) This is censure,

Submitted by ??????? (not verified) on 13 January, 2010 - 00:44.

Agree :) This is censure, but Turkish if they really want to access the information can find alternative ! i think. (home shopping catalogs | free online advertising)

hapy

Submitted by muzikdinle (not verified) on 12 January, 2010 - 15:36.

have signed this petition to protest Turkish government's ban on internet sites.Canl? Sohbet
I am appealing to all citizens of the world who care for civil rights and individual freedom of Müzik Dinle

Post new comment

News

» China Announces Arrests in Hacking Crackdown

» UK.gov moves to block Hamas kids site

» 'Shut Up'? Pakistan President's Outburst Scrubbed From 'Net

» The Internet in Iran is Crawling, Conveniently, Right Before Planned Protests

» How The Hackers Took Google: A Theory

» (Opinion) Why You Should Be Afraid Of Internet Censorship in Australia, Even If You Don’t Live There

» China Rebuffs Clinton on Internet Warning

» Net censorship campaign backfires

Herdict Web

Herdict Web allows Internet users to help document Web inaccessibility around the world. Try it out today!

Three Easy Steps to Block Sites in Turkey

Post new comment

News

Herdict Web

Email List Signup